by Peter on June 15, 2010
P.D. James always writes excellently, and this book is simply exceedingly well written. The prose is elegant, advanced, flowing and as always eminently readable.
Devices and Desires 
features Adam Dalgliesh and is set in Larksoken in Norfolk. It focuses on the lives of people in a small village community that lies in the shadow of a nuclear power station. James explores issues of community life and relationships – in particular the reactions of local people to the power station, and the workers – love, betrayal and the intricacies of the relationship between two siblings. Along the way we come across a nuclear protest organizer, a down-trodden artist and single parent, struggling with 4 children, and several other minor characters, who all have a significant part to play.
Slowly and meticulously P.D. James draws the reader into the story, and systematically she introduces the many characters that are relevant in this intriguing mystery. And our master detective, commander Adam Dalgliesh, remains for a long time a bystander on holiday at his late aunt’s cottage, while the local police are handling the case of “the Whistler” a mass murderer of young women in the community of Larksoken on the cost of Norfolk. When “the Whistler” claims his fifth victim, and Commander Dalgliesh is the one that finds the body of Hilary Robarts, he is drawn fully into the investigation.
The story in Devices and Desires is a dark one. Past events of a horrendous nature play a prominent part, and as the story progresses it becomes apparent that “the Whistler” is not the only murderer.
The mystery is elegantly solved, in a way that makes the seeming disparate pieces of James’ puzzle all fall into their places. Devices and Desires is a great mystery novel, but one of P.D. James darker ones – a book with much suffering and distress.
Two bodies are 
discovered with their throats slashed in a London church. They lie in a welter of blood. One of the victims is a very prominent man: Sir Paul Berowne, former Minister of the Crown. The other victim, Harry Mack, is a tramp, a man accustomed to sleeping in the church vestibule.
Now Adam Dalgliesh and his detectives must find out why they were both killed like this. Was there a connection between the two men – unlikely as it may seem? Dalgliesh and his team, set up to investigate crimes of particular sensitivity, are faced with a case of extraordinary complexity as they discover the Berowne family’s veneer of prosperous gentility conceals ugly and dangerous secrets. It also seems the deaths may be tied to those of two young women who have recently been employed in the Berowne household.
A Taste for Death is gripping from start to finish. Dalgliesh is caught up in an investigation which has turned personal – he knew Berowne. There are many twists and turns in this complex investigation, as the detectives try to unravel the clues and evidence to point them to a ruthless and sadistic killer. And there are, of course, lots of clues that will lead you astray as well, but ultimately it comes down to one ruthless murderer.
This is a wonderful, complex mystery with a very good plot. It is also, in my opinion, the best book P. D. James had so far written. It has excellent characters, is very rich on the descriptive side and builds the story with great care, and the narrative is simply excellent. It is also very interesting in the way it develops the character of Adam Dalgliesh, and makes him an ever more credible protagonist. The ending of A Taste for Death is both poignant and surprising. If you haven’t read this one yet, so grab it and get going!
This mystery was 
published in 1977. It is an interesting book for a number of reasons, but one of them is that the murder that starts off the book, that of a young girl is not at all the focus of this book. Rather it is a quite different murder – that of Dr. Lorrimer, a very experienced expert witness and highly respected academic, who was found dead one morning in his lab, with his skull smashed in, which is the book’s real focus. The first murder actually serves a different purpose; to introduce readers to the staff of a forensic laboratory, the background of this mystery.
Commander Adam Dalgliesh and his associate Detective Investigator the Honorable John Massingham are called in to investigate the Lorrimer murder. Dr. Edwin Lorrimer was respected but not well-liked, and even hated by quite a few. He was not a pleasant man – he was bad-tempered, petty, smallish, bitter and vindictive – and he had insulted many people over the years. The suspects of this murder are all limited to the lab, but even so there are several possible suspects; almost too many motives and no physical evidence to go by.
Dalgliesh is left to use his deductive skills to find who among the suspects the killer is. Then the killer decides to claim a second victim Stella Mawson.
This is another very crafty mystery novel by P.D. James. The setting is memorable, the plot is complex, the characters are very alive and believable, and all elements of the tales are wowen together in a suspenseful fashion. Death of an Expert Witness is a very elegant mystery book, quite engaging and a pleasure to read.
Praise:
‘P. D. James is one of the national treasures of British fiction… Each new book gives pleasure not just for macabre crimes or ingenious solutions but its density of experience.’ –Malcolm Bradbury, Mail on Sunday
‘Unlike so many crime writers, James still has the power to move, fascinate and astonish.’ –Independent
by Peter on April 10, 2010
The Black Tower has been cited as one of 
the best 100 greatest mystery novels of all time. In my opinion it is a great book, but actually more as a psychological novel or thriller than as a classical mystery book. For sure, it is the creepiest of P. D. James’s works. There are multiple murder victims, a very dense, strange and claustrophobic setting — an isolated nursing home on the Dorset coast — and lots of suspense.
Commander Adam Dalgliesh, having just recovered from a grave illness, receives an invitation to visit his old friend and mentor Father Baddely. Something is amiss and the ageing chaplain would like Dalgliesh’s advice. Dalgliesh decides that a visit to the countryside might give him time to relax and give thought to perhaps giving up his career at Scotland Yard. But when Dalgliesh arrives, he finds his old friend has died a few days earlier. And there is no rest, as there are a series of deaths at Troynton Grange, and with each death Dalgliesh is drawn inexorably back into his old life, solving murders.
In The Black Tower, Dalgliesh is more an observer of what is happening than usual. And when the solution comes to him, it is more his intuition than logical deductions that leads him to it.
The Black Tower is a strong novel, and very exciting, but also slightly different from most of the other Dalgliesh novels. The characters are not as well developed as we have become accustomed to, and the book is darker and gloomier than usual.
Splendid, macabre” – London Sunday Telegraph
“The Black Tower is a masterpiece.” – London Sunday Times
by Peter on April 9, 2010
The New York Times called Shroud for a Nightingale “mystery at its best.”
The fourth novel in the Adam Dalgliesh series, aptly 
titled Shroud for a Nightingale, P. D James shows readers, for the first time, a new side of her vast crime fiction writing abilities. This time she dives deeply into a complex and dark setting, the Nightingale House, and more fully than before develops the characters there. And it simply is a great pleasure to read the novel and see and feel the extent to which she succeeds in this venture. They are creatures of flesh and blood, with feelings and personal histories.
The novel is almost a horror story, albeit one cast in an unusually elegant prose, and with a mystery that is, of course, in the end solved by Adam Dalgliesh. But feeling of terror that is present all the way from the start of the novel, the horrors of deception and betrayal, long-buried secrets, repressed sexuality, a double murder, and the other black elements are not any less scaring because they are elegantly described. In a way, I would rather say it is the opposite.
The young women of Nightingale House are there to learn to nurse and comfort the suffering. But when one of the students plays patient in a demonstration of nursing skills, she is horribly, brutally killed. Another student dies equally mysteriously. It is up to Adam Dalgliesh of Scotland Yard to unmask a killer who has decided to prescribe murder as the cure for all ills.
This very suspense-filled novel by P.D. James is elegantly plotted and poses a mystery that will keep you guessing until the end as to the truth of the deaths and the truth about the nurses, the doctors, the instructors at this very deadly hospital. The complex case also displays Adam Dalgliesh in a very interesting manner. Shroud for a Nightingale is a wonderful crime novel. A classic crime fiction novel, P.D. James at her very best; provocative and thrilling, full of clues and red herrings. And, when it is revealed, a story with a somewhat shocking murder motive.
by Peter on April 5, 2010
This is a very complex mystery featuring Adam Dalgliesh. 
Unnatural Causes is a book some readers like a lot, and some readers think is one of the least interesting novels in the Adam Dalgliesh series. The reason, to my mind, is that the mystery this time is very complex. Some readers simply lose interest in the mystery before the solution is revealed.
A famous mystery writer, Maurice Seton, is found dead at the bottom of a dinghy, with both hands chopped off at the wrists. Seton had imagined many ugly murders, but his own was bad beyond his imaginative power. His horrible death scares his strange neighbors.
Superintendent Adam Dalgliesh had been looking forward to a quiet holiday at his Aunt Jane’s cottage on Monksmere Head, one of the furthest-flung spots on the remote Suffolk coast. He was hoping to enjoy the scenery, go for long walks, drink his tea in peace in front of the fireplace and listen to the sound of the fire. It was a well-earned break. However, the murder shattered the peace. Now it is instead up to Superintendent Adam Dalgliesh, with some help from his remarkable Aunt Jane, to discover who typed the writer’s death sentence before the plot takes another murderous turn.
I belong to the group of readers who doesn’t rank this mystery among the best in the series. What I enjoyed in this book was more the feeling of getting to know Adam Dalgliesh better – P.D. James lets us learn quite a bit about him in this book. Also, I enjoyed the writing style, the humor and all the odd and intriguing things going on in the strange community James has invented for this book. So to me Unnatural Causes does not rank among the best in the series but is still well worth reading.
“P.D. James scores with understated humor, stately yet unpretentious prose, psychological insights…plus, above all, fundamental warmth and wisdom in every line she writes.”–Kirkus Reviews
, 
, and 
.
